I’m sure Jim and Claire would visit a lot.
They have to stay with the trolls, to protect them and the new heart stone (in possibly New Jersey) but they have a lot in Arcadia they would never just leave all that behind to only visit once. I mean their best friends, parents and Claire’s baby brother.
I can see them coming back for holidays, possible adventures (Arcadia just attracts the weird), and special events like graduations, weddings (stricklake wedding I hope) and maybe birthdays. :)











